tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post4477755515678853274..comments2024-03-18T22:39:50.137-07:00Comments on A Kindle World blog: Thoughts on the iPad from an e-book reader point of viewAnonymoushttp://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comBlogger29125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-66540053823146889982010-01-28T14:28:28.075-08:002010-01-28T14:28:28.075-08:00I have images of my DX displaying PDFs in vertical...I have images of my DX displaying PDFs in vertical and horizontal and web pages also, and next to the Kindle 2.<br /><br /> <a href="http://bit.ly/kpics" rel="nofollow">http://bit.ly/kpics</a><br /><br /> MY experience with PDFs on the DX is good with only a horrible sample from someone who had a physics PDF in pure gray and it was hardly readable.<br /><br /> Remember you can try it out for up to 30 days and return it for ANY reason for a full refund.<br /><br /> But check out the pics. Let me know what you think. I put a lot of electronics manuals on it. (I don't think the iPad mentioned PDF as a format yet -- maybe developing it or a problem with Adobe -- since they don't use flash while Adobe offered to work with them and they don't use Adobe's digital rights management over the ePub files.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-14092188589041744962010-01-28T14:17:41.682-08:002010-01-28T14:17:41.682-08:00I'm still trying to figure out how viewing PDF...I'm still trying to figure out how viewing PDFs on the Kindle DX really is. What is the experience of viewing textbooks or certification books that are in PDF form on the Kindle DX. I was holding off on purchasing an ereader because of waiting to see what Apple will do. I already have a workstation, laptop, and iPhone 3GS, so the iPad is a no-go as far as I'm concerned. I've been able to test out the Kindle 2 and it is great for reading novels, but it doesn't handle PDFs well at all. Please share your experiences and thoughts about PDFs on the Kindle DX.eha1990https://www.blogger.com/profile/12965391255169688323noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-82617543879631760682010-01-28T11:51:54.073-08:002010-01-28T11:51:54.073-08:00Apple approved the one for iPod long ago, so they&...Apple approved the one for iPod long ago, so they'd need a good reason. They have already been called in to explain that business practice (the Google rejection) and need to be careful.<br />That was supposedly, as you say, based on a replacement of a core function and user interface but the Kindle store is a very external entity. Whatever, they can't make a case for allowing iPod and iPhone but not iPad.<br /><br /> However, ya never know :-)<br /><br /> Amazon said the other day, though, that the Kindle for iPad app is one of the options for Kindle owners during a response to a reporter asking about the iPad.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-87508124247531757342010-01-28T11:40:04.571-08:002010-01-28T11:40:04.571-08:00I'll be (pleasantly) surprised if Apple approv...I'll be (pleasantly) surprised if Apple approves a "Kindle for iPad App" for its App Store. Apple didn't approve the Google Voice app, and didn't back down even when the FCC became involved. Here was Apple's response to an FCC inquiry:<br /><br />"Contrary to published reports, Apple has not rejected the Google Voice application, and continues to study it. The application has not been approved because, as submitted for review, it appears to alter the iPhone’s distinctive user experience by replacing the iPhone’s core mobile telephone functionality and Apple user interface with its own..."<br /><br />I can see Apple rejecting a Kindle for iPad App for the same reason, because now Apple has its own iBook app. Perhaps Apple would end up "looking weak", but unfortunately that hasn't stopped Apple from rejecting apps before.Kellyhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13465668371786466723noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-83740267889569226502010-01-28T10:16:39.432-08:002010-01-28T10:16:39.432-08:00Hi, Rick -
I thought the iPad is beautiful too,...Hi, Rick - <br /> I thought the iPad is beautiful too, still do. I had no problem with the name but have seen that others do (and I do know what the associations are). I'd always just thought of a notepad though.<br /><br /> There is, from what I understand, no way to power a hard drive from it. But the 16 gig (solid state memory) is not going to store very much before the sync'g between computer and iPad has to be done for file transfers.<br /><br /> NO USB port it turns out, but you can get an adapter for that.<br /><br /> I'm preparing a list of things that people should consider when buying one and I should be through soon.<br /><br /> I'm pretty sure that Mirasol color technology is going on a Kindle for probably late Fall. It has the reflective qualities of e-paper technologies and color and is also fast enough for video.<br /><br /> You're absolutely right. All the Skiff has is the newspaper/magazine group. I think it was very flexible/bendable though. But it would be limited in other ways.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-3427938625941485212010-01-28T10:03:49.704-08:002010-01-28T10:03:49.704-08:00I am not an Apple fanboy, but I thought the iPad (...I am not an Apple fanboy, but I thought the iPad (terrible name) was beautiful with a gorgeous screen. Still, assuming that you need 3G wuth the monthly plan, then it becomes very expensive for a device that just surfs the web, plays games and video downloads, and reading, especially newspapers. It's an iPhone without the phone!! For that it is over-priced.<br /><br />BUT, if I can get by with wifi and a small hardrive for a total of only $499, no monthly charges, that is a pretty good price, especially if I can use my Kindle app on it.<br /><br />I've never read on a handheld backlit screen,so I can't testify to the effect on my eyes, but love the kindle e-ink screen..However, Kindle MUST get color this year, AND it must be VERY GOOD color, even tough 95% of my rading is on books.<br /><br />By the way, I don;t see this as a Kindle killer- but it might be a Skiff-killer!<br />Rick AskenaseAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-29505207738282925802010-01-28T07:59:32.702-08:002010-01-28T07:59:32.702-08:00I "love" pulling books and rss feeds fro...I "love" pulling books and rss feeds from the air, but have more than ample access to wi-fi for an internet connection.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-60349677519928114882010-01-28T07:42:57.012-08:002010-01-28T07:42:57.012-08:00Anonymous,
So you don't care that much about...Anonymous,<br /> So you don't care that much about pulling books from the air? <br /><br /> It's good to be able to easily find older, good books that cost a lot less. <br /><br /> As for reselling e-books, I'm afraid that's never going to be possible. There's no way anyone can tell if you kept a copy for yourself. It'd be like reselling an mp3.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-76577555002110514692010-01-28T07:35:15.983-08:002010-01-28T07:35:15.983-08:00I could easily live with a wi-fi only kindle.
As...I could easily live with a wi-fi only kindle. <br /> As for book pricing, $9.99 is high for me. Most books I buy are used -- from amazon -- with a total cost of far less. If I could resell my kindle books to another kindle user, I would like that.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-44951800016375685632010-01-28T07:04:30.578-08:002010-01-28T07:04:30.578-08:00Scott,
I can read the Kindle for hours. On trips...Scott,<br /> I can read the Kindle for hours. On trips, it's been no different.<br /><br /> Have fun !Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-36606307688131820002010-01-28T06:59:34.413-08:002010-01-28T06:59:34.413-08:00I think the fundamental issue with the iPad (which...I think the fundamental issue with the iPad (which I see as a giant iPod Touch) is that it is still a back lit screen. I work in front of two LCD screens all day long and my eyes get tired from that reading. My Kindle does not give me that problem. I will be traveling next week and will be taking my Kindle with me and am anxious to see how the experience is over a long period of time.Unknownhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09674015018404087711noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-43738914709854777592010-01-28T03:02:09.337-08:002010-01-28T03:02:09.337-08:00Gorian,
No mention of pdf-reading yet but of cou...Gorian,<br /> No mention of pdf-reading yet but of course it'll have to have that. Same with annotations, searches, and dictionary. I just wonder if they're leaving that to developers to handle in their different ways. I wonder about Apple's working relationship with Adobe. The flash thing seems to have been a problem.<br /><br /> But they have another 2 months to go. It's beautiful. It makes sense to have both a Kindle and the iPad since they're so different and it'll be awhile before Apple gets all the functions working as well for an e-reader since it seems to have been one of the last items on their timeline.<br /><br /> I hope they keep updates coming.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-56974316253644977022010-01-28T02:48:04.255-08:002010-01-28T02:48:04.255-08:00iPad is no challenge to Kindle, but may find its p...iPad is no challenge to Kindle, but may find its popularity among college students as the ultimate tool for note-taking and pdf-reading. I have a Kindle but I still want one of those.Gorian Dopehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12496950817555724359noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-3018551876146340102010-01-28T00:56:35.929-08:002010-01-28T00:56:35.929-08:00Batman,
iEverything at least is a sort of identi...Batman,<br /> iEverything at least is a sort of identifying label. And then there's iRex and the iLiad.<br /><br /> "EnTourage eDGe" is just too contrived for me and it does actually set up a mild resentment that they put us through this. I think if I could understand the positives of the package more, over its drawbacks, it wouldn't irritate me as much.<br /><br /> Nevertheless, they did a beautiful job on the design. I wish they could make it slimmer and lighter if the e-paper screen can't be detachable and there can be no hard drive or keyboard.<br /><br /> There are a lot of tablets coming out and I think one would meet your needs this year.<br /><br /> The iPad's inability to multitask is, I think, a huge one. Someone wondered how Apple will be able to make an inline-dictionary for the reader but there must be a way. <br /><br /> Also, how can you have the best webbing experience ever (as they described it) when you can't access the content of the opening flash routines at so many sites. I don't like flash openings but I'd like less being kept out of the sites because my device couldn't do it (if the webperson neglected to make a 'skip flash' but entire websites (such as photography galleries) are made entirely of flash (and are unnecessarily slow).<br /><br /> At Gizmodo there was the really harsh review I mentioned (on Twitter) and then there is a very positive one which surprisingly drew jeers from the assembled, many of them Apple fans. <br /><br /> Someone said they'd not seen a split like this before, between Gizmodo writers and the commenters. I don't think the iPad will be huge. It'll sell but certainly not the way some expected.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-16546818923121046432010-01-28T00:36:50.477-08:002010-01-28T00:36:50.477-08:00My immediate thought/reaction was that the prospec...My immediate thought/reaction was that the prospects of this particular device *might* suit my desire for a approx. 8.5 x 11 slate form factor for reading magazines and newspapers (I'm not a "gamer," and the video/TV-watching capability would be a nice feature, but not a necessity, per se). Furthermore, I'm not sure the 3G capability is a must have for me, as I'm (sadly) usually either at work or home, so the Wi-Fi would probably be enough (although I might find I'd regret not having it). And I definitely don't want more data charges, even on a pay-as-you-go basis. So all in all, I like the idea of the iPad, but at the current price structure, it's not compelling enough for me to take the plunge at this time. Maybe a later iteration, or a better fit by one of Apple's competitors...?<br /><br />I just realized I didn't say anything about the e-book aspects(!). I only saw the photos from the live blogs, so I probably need to check out some videos, but the "iBooks" were very visually appealing. If the e-ink screens ever became closer to white than gray, those would probably be aesthetically sufficient for my personal reading, but the iPad's was more pleasing to my eye at first blush.<br /><br />However, your points are well taken about the dictionary, annotations, etc. And those are some of the things I've probably come to take for granted, even in the relatively short time I've had a Kindle, so it's good to be reminded to include those in the purchase decision criteria. I thought I read somewhere today that there was some ability to sample books, which I've come to view as almost indispensable to my e-book reading habits, so that would be a plus.<br /><br />So, it seems like you and your blogosphere colleagues have quite a bit to chew on over the immediate future! I'm sure that these are the times that give you extra energy for those late night posts. One last thing - with regard to our exchanges about "quirky" product names (e.g., "eDGe"), how did "iPad" strike you? Take care.Batman Jr.noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-30881603608996248442010-01-28T00:06:45.430-08:002010-01-28T00:06:45.430-08:00Batman,
I took the $740 from the transcript as s...Batman,<br /> I took the $740 from the transcript as shown in the orange colored blockquote.<br /><br /> But it's $130 above WiFi prices, yes. Will make a note about that tomorrow, probably.<br /><br /> Thanks. Do you have any other thoughts about this landmark occasion?Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-40473190288669570392010-01-27T23:59:03.365-08:002010-01-27T23:59:03.365-08:00Hi Andrys,
Just a slight correction to your price...Hi Andrys,<br /><br />Just a slight correction to your price list: The 32 GB version would be $730 ($729), rather than $740. I know it doesn't change your larger points, but you know I'm a frustrated editor ;-0 . Take care.Batman Jr.noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-81315256127585574672010-01-27T23:13:02.021-08:002010-01-27T23:13:02.021-08:00Troy, let's hope it's very soon, though th...Troy, let's hope it's very soon, though they've been absolutely silent on the matter. The university studies may have some influence though.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-91600729698638013622010-01-27T22:58:33.946-08:002010-01-27T22:58:33.946-08:00"they will HAVE to add these with the proper ..."they will HAVE to add these with the proper Adobe license if they want this in the universities or in business environments and to interest people like you."<br /><br />INDEED!!!Troy Omafrayhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/11413593202172947441noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-6115811156394204982010-01-27T20:00:21.501-08:002010-01-27T20:00:21.501-08:00Mike, did you get rid of the DX before the v2.3 up...Mike, did you get rid of the DX before the v2.3 update that fixed PDF margin cropping to optimize the use of space in Landscape for text? Made it much more readable. Fonts are enlarged as a result to meet the ends of the screen.<br /><br /> The reflowing would have been for converted PDFs as there's no reflow with use of the actual PDF.<br /><br /> BUT the problem with multi-column PDFS going up and down and then our having to go back and forth is a real one. <br /> They need a real zoom on it.<br /><br /> There are no annotations possible for the PDF, which is a large drawback for anyone needing to work with the PDF (though i have suggested using it for visual reference and making notes on a converted copy -- this is what studios and agencies in Hollywood are doing, per two reports I blogged). <br /><br /> There is no way to enlarge PDF fonts (except to rotate it, which leaves only 1 size change) No dictionary support, no text to speech, no highlighting or notes. To my mind, they will HAVE to add these with the proper Adobe license if they want this in the universities or in business environments and to interest people like you.<br /><br /> Have you looked at Plastic Logic's Que for the PDF needs? It's gray scale only but it promises to be very good for business needs.<br /><br /> Thanks for the feedback.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-69021458768377929562010-01-27T19:44:39.810-08:002010-01-27T19:44:39.810-08:00Sorry, I didn't have a good experience with PD...Sorry, I didn't have a good experience with PDFs and annotations on Kindle DX. I sold it right after. I'm the type of guy who wants to read technical resources such as the Safari Books Online site, textbooks in PDFs and so on. I bought Kindle DX for that purpose and it failed to impress me. It doesn't do well with margin cropping, crappy reflowing/text font sizes and there was no dictionary support for it either. It didn't work well for me.<br /><br />iPad in this case might actually be the only device that can handle what I want but at the moment, you're right about the lack of highlighting, annotations, and dictionary support. Not to mention the serious lack of multitasking as well. Hopefully Apple can do something to impress me to get iPad, maybe multitasking support in iPhone 4.0? All we can do is hope. The thing about iPad, its the software that can change to people's need, Kindle is far too slow to adapt.MikhailThttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00833925825084193143noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-84511865123831998202010-01-27T17:09:20.683-08:002010-01-27T17:09:20.683-08:00Christopher,
Exactly. And that point is made in...Christopher,<br /> Exactly. And that point is made in my blog entry but is likely hidden by all that verbiage :-)Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-31549289172275564332010-01-27T17:06:56.146-08:002010-01-27T17:06:56.146-08:00There's also the very interesting point that n...There's also the very interesting point that needs to be made about the kindle reader for the iphone/ipod touch, which would now be available for the ipad...Christopher Hylaridesnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-49490458896470267422010-01-27T17:02:32.542-08:002010-01-27T17:02:32.542-08:00Christopher,
I agree with you on that smart pric...Christopher,<br /> I agree with you on that smart pricing, which was necessary, from what we see.<br /><br /> As a traveler, I pack my DX and my 10" netbook and cannot imagine replacing those two with the ePad. Nor would I pack it as an additional item.<br /><br /> If travelling but not needing to do work on it or read novels as you say, AND wanting to catch up on magazines and the daily newspaper, then yes, it's very attractive to those with the means.<br /><br /> I do think the reality-based Base price is the $740 one, once someone can afford it all + the $15 or $30 per a given month. AND reading periodicals on the home WIFI makes this a doable price. <br /><br /> I want to see how they work the 2-iPads in a home situation and sharing of newspapers and magazine subscirptions, as that is the Kindle's weaker point for subscriptions, driven by publisher demands, I read.<br /><br /> Re ePub, it's my take that this support will come pretty soon (it's just too needed) and that Amazon gave it less priority when each roll-out of a new capability gives it more buzz more often.<br /><br /> They own Lexcycle which does Stanza, whose main thing is ePub. Non-DRM'd ePub is just a natural and no threat to the Kindlestore except for the fact that so much is available on ePub that people might buy fewer books.<br /><br /> But if they don't do this, people would buy fewer Kindles :-) and stay less attached to Amazon's Kindlestore as main store.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05109282436243758435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-872447660964013545.post-27949637607396793202010-01-27T16:49:09.175-08:002010-01-27T16:49:09.175-08:00"Elegant Jack of all trades, Master of none&q..."Elegant Jack of all trades, Master of none" is really what this boils down to. If you read novels, this isn't for you. Reading a novel for 4+ hours on this is going to kill the eyes. If what you want is to read magazines, newspapers, and browse the web, as well as watch movies plus whatever apps get written for it (do not underestimate this) then it's an exciting play. The price point was lower than what everybody was expecting. Travelers may like the more compact, but expanded feature set of the iPad (especially since it can do pages presentations as well).<br /><br />It'll be interesting to see what version 2 will give, as Apple will respond to signals of what people want it to evolve into. Amazon is doing the same thing with the kindle. Meanwhile, will most people who already have an iPhone/iPod touch really get that much else out of this?<br /><br />Also, why the hell doesn't the kindle support epub? There's no reason for it to support mobi, pdf, etc but not epub.Christopher Hylaridesnoreply@blogger.com